May Comeback 4-Pack

Back from the vault. Only for May.

We’ve opened the cookie vault for a special treat — the May Comeback 4-Pack features four of our most legendary, best-selling flavors, available for this month only. These fan favorites sold out fast the first time around, and now they’re back to make your May a whole lot sweeter.

Included Flavors:

🍀 Hoppy-Go-Lucky
A Biscoff® Lucky Charms™ Cookie
A green-dyed cookie butter base packed with Lucky Charms™ marshmallows, Biscoff® cookies, white chocolate chips, and Pillsbury™ Mini Lucky Charms™ Cookies. Stuffed with no-bake Biscoff® cheesecake on a Biscoff® crust and Lucky Charms™ cereal milk buttercream. Finished with Biscoff® white chocolate frosting and Lucky Charms™ marshmallows.

☁️ Marshmallow Sky
A Cookie Dough Marshmallow Cookie
A soft blue sugar cookie base with mini marshmallows, white chocolate chips, cookie dough chunks, and brownie chunks. Stuffed with marshmallow fluff and a homemade fudge brownie. Topped with a white chocolate shell and mini dehydrated marshmallows.

🥜 Fudgin’ Nutty
A Peanut Butter Buckeye-Inspired Cookie
Peanut butter fudge base loaded with peanut butter cream pies, Nestlé® peanut butter chocolate chips, and Reese’s® Peanut Butter Cups. Stuffed with peanut butter and fudge frosting. Dipped in milk chocolate and a touch of peanut butter.

🎉 Oreo’s Birthday
An Oreo® Cake Batter Cookie
A cake batter sugar cookie packed with Cosmic Brownies™, Birthday Cake Oreo® cookies, rainbow sprinkles, and cream cheese chips. Stuffed with an Oreo® truffle dipped in white chocolate and funfetti frosting. Topped with white chocolate drizzle, Oreo® crumbs, and extra sprinkles.

📦 Available through May 31st only — then back into the vault they go!
Treat yourself or send as a gift — either way, don’t wait.